Shari Woodbury, U.U. Minister
  • Home
  • About
    • Journey
    • Theology
    • Vocation
    • Honors
  • Ministry
    • Worship
    • Religious Education
    • Pastoral Care
    • Rites & RItuals
    • Creative Arts
  • Leadership
    • Social Action
    • Administration
    • Service
    • Personality
    • Beyond UU
  • Personal
    • Family
    • Interests
    • Gratitude
  • BLOGS
    • Savvy Seeker
    • Roots & Wings

Roots & Wings

 

Humanism in the Heartland

10/11/2026

0 Comments

 

A UU Tale

Adapted from a sermon delivered October 11, 2026 at First Unitarian Church of Omaha. (Video available below or on YouTube here.)
“So many stories of where I've been, and how I got to where I am…” That’s as true for a faith tradition as it is for an individual. This morning as we continue plumbing our October theme, Living the Questions, we turn to one facet of where Unitarian Universalism has been and how it got to where we are today.
 
We turn to a group of people who came to be known as humanists. These are people who, like many Unitarian Universalists (or UUs) today, were not necessarily satisfied with inherited answers to perennial religious and ethical questions.
 
As science and the theory of evolution penetrated Western culture, liberal Christians – including our Unitarian and Universalists forebears – had to wrestle with questions of what place, if any, the supernatural continued to have in faith. Also in the 1800s, higher criticism was brought to bear on scriptures; scholars considered alternate ways to understand miracles in the Bible, through the forces of nature and through the symbolism of literature. Studies of folklore and comparative religion further challenged the uniqueness and superiority of conventional Christianity.
 
That is the backdrop to the emergence of humanism. The values of humanism that members of our Atheists, Humanists and Agnostics (AHA) group shared in the reading, come from the most recent expression of humanist values. You may have noticed that they overlap significantly with the values of Unitarian Universalism (or UUism for short). Indeed, among those humanist values – altruism, critical thinking, empathy, environmentalism, ethical development, global awareness, humility, peace and social justice, responsibility, service and participation – all are consistent with UU commitments and culture.
 
This is more than coincidence. Unitarians played an important role in the emergence of humanism in this country, and humanism has remained a core strand in our pluralistic faith ever since.
 
In his 2002 book, Making the Manifesto, Unitarian Universalist minister and denominational leader William Schulz explains his reason for illuminating the birth of religious humanism:  
“if all of us understood better where religious humanism came from” Schulz writes, “– the battles it fought, the assumptions it purchased, the victories it claimed, and the limitations it fostered – we would be better equipped today to integrate its theology into our religious world view, to draw the best from its inspiration, and to avoid the pitfalls to which it once succumbed.”
[a sharply dressed man pokes out from behind high pulpit…] 
 
Oh my goodness!  I recognize you, this is most unexpected. In fact, how can you be here, in 2026? Well no matter, I take it you have something to share on this topic?  Folks, please help me give a warm welcome to a colleague from another era.

COMMENTS BY R. LESTER MONDALE

(written and delivered by Dave Richardson, a lay leader, historian for First Unitarian Church of Omaha, and a member of AHA; shared here with his permission)
Greetings from the past! My name is Reverend Robert Lester Mondale. You may recognize my surname because my younger half-brother was Walter Mondale, Vice President of the United States from 1976 to 1980.        
 
I have the distinction of being the only person who signed all three of the Humanist Manifestos. 1933, 1973 and 2003.  I signed the last version a few months before my 100th birthday.
Picture
R. Lester Mondale
(Photo courtesy of findagrave.com)
The original 1933 version was shepherded to completion by Raymond Bragg. It was published with 34 signers 15 of whom were Unitarian ministers, including Rev. John Dietrich and Rev. Curtis Reese, both very prominent figures in Unitarianism. The strong presence of the Unitarian ministers among the signers helped many Unitarian ministers, congregations and individuals to accept humanism.

Unlike the later manifestos, this first talks of Humanism as a new religion and refers to humanism as "the religion of the future." But it is careful not to express a creed or dogma. The document outlined fifteen affirmations on cosmology (the origin of the universe), biological and cultural evolution, human nature, epistemology, (the theory of knowledge) ethics, religion, self-fulfillment, and the quest for freedom and social justice. It also stated opposition to "acquisitive and profit-motivated society.” It also calls for voluntary mutual cooperation.
 
The 1973 Humanist Manifesto II begins with a statement that the excesses of National Socialism, fascism and world war had made the first Manifesto seem too optimistic. It placed emphasis on science and reasoning. In addition to its absolute rejection of theism, deism, and belief in credible proof of any afterlife.
 
The 2003 Manifesto affirmed the role of evolution, ethical values, nature and the importance of participation in the service of human ideals. It also asserts that humans are an integral part of nature,  
 
For a period in the early 1920’s your church was served by a young Humanist minister named Charles Lyttle who focused on humanism in his sermons. He later went on to publish several important works on the Westward movement of Unitarianism and its humanist influences. The book is titled Freedom Moves West.
 
I am proud to have been part of the Humanist Manifestos from the beginning. I am also grateful that it remains a key element for many UUs today. I am also very pleased that your church has an active humanist presence.
[Rev. Mondale took a seat after concluding his remarks.]
Thank you, Rev. Mondale for that firsthand insight into Unitarian and humanist history.
 
The bigger picture helps explain how religious humanism emerged from and has largely remained within Unitarianism. You see, Unitarianism itself developed from a non-creedal, big-tent stance, pushed out of Congregationalism by those who favored clear, doctrinal answers over open questions.
 
The fledgling Unitarian tradition had already stretched its theological boundaries once before, when the Transcendentalists like Emerson, Thoreau and Fuller explored sacred writings of the East – opening  the door to recognizing wisdom in “world religion” as well as the Jesus tradition – emphasizing personal spiritual experience, even mysticism, and conscience. That happened soon after the founding of Unitarianism, in the early to mid-1800s. While the Transcendentalists pulled Unitarianism beyond biblical rationalism, they still embraced their Christian roots, including theism.
 
The movement that would come to be known as humanist was the next test of Unitarianism’s ability to live the questions. This one found firm footing in the Western Conference of the denomination that had been established by that point – those “western” congregations were concentrated in the Midwest at that time.
 
If you were here for the opening installment of my Midwest Heritage series in January, you may remember that historically, compared to the East or the South of the United States, the Midwest was less class-bound, more democratic, more universal and lifelong in its embrace of education, and more open to new ideas.
 
So perhaps it should come as no surprise that within Unitarianism, new ways of understanding religion found fertile ground here. Freethinking ministers were more likely to come to serve churches in this region, wherever they might have originally been from – especially since the Western Unitarian Conference, under the leadership of Jenkin Lloyd Jones, eschewed all tests of belief – welcoming all who wished to serve the higher good to do so in the (mid)west.
 
Among the most prominent early organizers of religious humanism – the kind of humanism that led to the first Humanist Manifesto in 1933 – were two Unitarian ministers serving in the Midwest. William Schulz traces the beginnings of religious humanism to a meeting of John Dietrich and Curtis Reese at a session of the Western Unitarian Conference that met in Des Moines in 1917.
Picture
Picture
Picture
John Dietrich, Curtis W. Reese, and Raymond Bragg
​(photos courtesy of the Dictionary of Unitarian & Universalist Biographies)
John Dietrich served First Unitarian Society in Minneapolis, which to this day retains its identity as birthplace of religions humanism. Dietrich avoided use of God-language, but he did not declare himself an atheist, either. He simply focused attention on how human efforts, inspired by religious values, could make a difference in the world.
 
Curtis Reese served First Unitarian Church in Des Moines. Reese took what he called a democratic view of religion, rather than a theocratic or autocratic one. He lifted up science for problem-solving and emphasized human effort for human welfare, including designing social policies consistent with humanitarian religious values. Reese’s tenure in the parish was shorter, as he would soon take over leadership of the Western Unitarian Conference.
 
Schulz traces much of the framework for the first Humanist Manifesto to Dietrich’s writing and speaking on the topic. However, it was Reese who believed himself to have preached “the first systematically Humanist sermon preached from any pulpit in America” in an address titled “A Democratic View of Religion.” It was in distributing that text at the conference gathering in 1917 that Reese and Dietrich connected and became collaborators in building a movement of religious humanism. Between Dietrich’s sermons and the four books on humanism that Reese would write, they established the contours of religious humanism.
 
Those ideas first came before a larger Unitarian audience in 1919, when Dietrich’s essay on “The Religion of Experience” graced the cover of the Christian Register, a weekly newspaper published by the American Unitarian Association – one of the forerunners of the UU World magazine we know today. Dietrich’s essay did not recognize supernatural intervention, focusing on the need for people to rely upon human effort. The piece drew a lively stream of letters from readers in response, both pro and con.
 
What was God, and was God essential or optional or obsolete? Advocates with diverse perspectives began to express their takes on the topic, in Unitarian publications and at meetings of the Western Unitarian Conference. One watershed moment was at a Western Unitarian Conference meeting in Detroit in 1921. After presentations from both humanists like Dietrich and traditional theists, one of the theists inadvertently brought sympathy to Dietrich. It wasn’t so much the substance of what he said, as his tone and dismissive attitude toward the humanists.
 
Schulz notes that “Humanism won a great victory in Detroit – not in terms of gaining converts to its thinking but in terms of the national denomination’s refusal to pass any kind of statement that would banish humanists from the church.”  In other words, Unitarianism would remain a big-tent tradition, with no requirement of belief.
 
Through the rest of the 1920s and into the 30s, humanism grew in strength and influence within the Unitarian tradition. Strident objections to humanism calmed, though there were still occasional theistic criticisms. One of Curtis Reese’s letters in reply to one such critic is useful for illuminating what exactly was meant by the term, humanism. 
Reese “insisted that humanism is not materialism (which is mechanistic, while humanism is organic); not positivism (which worships humanity, while humanism holds that ‘Humanity is an abstraction having no concrete counterpart in objective reality’); not rationalism (which worships reason dogmatically, while humanism depends on intelligence and experience and trusts even them only experimentally); and not atheism (which is a denial of God, while humanism takes a position of inquiry).”  ~ William F. Schulz
Though it emerged from within Unitarianism – and remains a strong strand in our tradition – as religious humanism became more known, it attracted adherents from beyond Unitarianism.
 
A second generation of Unitarian humanists were centered in Chicago. They trained at Meadville Lombard Theological School, our UU seminary which by then had relocated to Chicago (my alma mater). But a professor of comparative religion at the University of Chicago named Eustace Haydon – who had been a Baptist minister before pursuing academia – became another proponent of religious humanism, now outside Unitarianism. He brought the cross-cultural perspective of anthropology to religion.
 
Haydon prompted the creation of a new organization, the Humanist Fellowship, established in 1927. Unitarians were still involved as this was a joint project of people associated with Meadville Lombard, the Unitarian seminary in Chicago, but also of the University of Chicago’s Divinity School. A new generation of humanists were organizing, and were no longer limited to Unitarian environs.
 
That new organization, the Humanist Fellowship, with the encouragement of Eustace Haydon began to publish a magazine, the New Humanist, in 1928. Contributors advocated for new liturgy and rituals suitable for humanist pulpits. While Reese and Dietrich had been reluctant to entirely give up traditional religious language, the up-and-coming humanists embraced new language. They also reclaimed intuition, mystery, and a kind of poetic naturalism, which had been downplayed amid the first generation’s emphasis on science, rationality and linear thinking. (This sounds like a recapitulation of earlier dynamics in Unitarianism, with the Transcendentalists.)  Rev. Lester Mondale, whom we heard from earlier, felt that human psychological needs were under-appreciated in the first strain of humanism, and spoke eloquently about the need to meet seekers as whole persons.

The New Humanist magazine was successful in spreading interest in humanism within intellectual circles, including universities. Books by Curtis Reese, Eustace Haydon and others helped even more people learn about humanism, and made the perspective more established.
 
As for the Humanist Manifesto? Curtis Reese’s successor as head of the Western Unitarian Conference, a man named Raymond Bragg, masterminded the development of a relatively short statement to summarize and publicize what humanism stood for. Bragg prevailed upon the philosopher and humanist Roy Wood Sellars, a professor at the University of Michigan, to draft the statement. Bragg then called upon others to join him in editing and finalizing the manifesto, including Eustace Haydon, Curtis Reese, and another Unitarian colleague in Chicago. 
Picture
The humanist logo (Wikimedia Commons)
The original Humanist Manifesto was published in the New Humanist in 1933. As Rev. Mondale noted earlier, 15 of the 34 signers were Unitarian ministers. (Another was a Universalist.) It’s hard to imagine how the project could have developed if the ethos of religious humanism had not been incubated within our Unitarian tradition.
The original manifesto would be succeeded by the Humanist Manifesto II in 1973 and most recently the Manifesto #3 in 2003. Much as Unitarian Universalism is a Living Tradition, one that regards revelation as unsealed, and whose principles and values are periodically reviewed and expressed afresh… so too has humanism continued to evolve. The succession of manifestos reflects the evolution of humanist thought.
 
Rev. Mondale pointed to some of the changes in the manifestos over time – becoming resolutely atheistic by the second manifesto, correcting the naive optimism of the first manifesto, valuing other species and the planet – those are some of the most striking changes. The American Humanist Association was formed in 1941, giving secular humanism its own organizational home. Hence the second and third manifestos are more reflective of secular humanism and far less tied to Unitarianism.
 
Unitarian Universalism remains the primary home of religious humanists today. And humanism has so penetrated our tradition that I see it as the common denominator across various other differences among us, including spiritual or theological differences. Just about every UU can agree on holding and seeking to live out humanist values – though some of us may also go beyond them. As Bill Schulz put it,
“I doubt if there is a single theist, Christian, or advocate of earth-centered spirituality within Unitarian Universalism today who would not affirm these tenets [of humanism]. Most of them would just not stop there.”
Schulz believes we are well beyond the old humanist-theist controversy, not only because humanist values have been absorbed into Unitarian Universalism (and indeed, into large swaths of society), but also because seekers today are welcomed to explore widely while keeping a home in UUism:  to take up a meditation practice tied to Eastern traditions, to participate in rituals that put one in sync with the rhythms of nature, and, Schulz writes, “to use richer language, and wrestle with deeper questions” than humanism often has – if one is drawn to do so in their own spiritual journey.
 
Like Rev. Mondale, I treasure the humanist heritage that is part of both our UU tradition and – for those of us in the heartland – that has all over it the fingerprints of our freethinking Midwest heritage too.

If you are curious to learn more about humanism, or to participate in lively conversations, I encourage you to join First Unitarian's Atheists, Humanists & Agnostics group on the first Saturday of every month to continue Living the Questions.
This is the full service in which the above sermon was delivered. A reading on Humanist Values Today, sharing a brief version of the ten values of humanism,  begins around 28:30. That is followed by a moving rendition of Brandi Carlisle's song "The Story" by Cadie Lammers. The sermon begins around 36:15. 
Source
 
Making the Manifesto: The Birth of Religious Humanism by William F. Schulz (Boston: Skinner House Books, 2002).
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    NOTICE:  ​ NO A.I. Training

    Click for details.

    Article List

    A list of all articles by title and date, grouped by topics.
          - Go to list -

    Author

    Shari Woodbury - Wanderer, worshiper, lover of learning, longing for the evolUUtion of spiritual community.

    Photo

    Banner photo from Asyarey / Unsplash

    Other Voices

    Disrupt Church also future-oriented
    Hold My Chalice in the trenches, er, pews
    It's Not About the Lattes on what millennials want
    Religion/Tech other lenses on spirituality

    Archives

    October 2026
    July 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025

    Categories

    All
    Abolition
    American Nations
    Black Lives Matter
    Bond Of Union
    Buildings
    Capitalism
    Charles Lyttle
    Christian Socialism
    Civic Culture
    Civil Disobedience
    Civil Rights
    Colin Woodard
    Colonization
    Community
    Community-building
    Compensation
    Consent Of The Governed
    Curtis W. Reese
    Democracy
    Development
    Discernment
    Easter
    Education
    Egalitarianism
    Ephraim Nute
    Eugene V. Debs
    Evolution
    Fellowship Movement
    Fetzer Institute
    Flexibility
    Food
    Fort Madison
    Gender Roles
    Great Emergence
    Henry David Thoreau
    Humanism
    ICE
    Innovation
    Iowa
    Iowa Sisterhood
    James Luther Adams
    Jenkin Lloyd Jones
    John Dietrich
    Jon Lauck
    Karen Bellavance-Grace
    Kenneth Patton
    KS
    Lawrence
    Lectionary
    Lester Mondale
    Little House On The Prairie
    Liturgy
    Mary Safford
    Meet The Moment
    Midwest
    Minneapolis
    Music
    Native Americans
    Noncompliace
    Numeric Growth
    Outreach
    Parish Ministry
    Pietist Universalists
    Practices
    Pragmatism
    Public Intellectual
    Radical Solidarity
    Regionalism
    Relationships
    Resisting Oppression
    Ritual
    Role Overload
    Salt Of The Earth
    Sermon Prep
    Shared Ministry
    Singing
    Slavery
    Small Group Ministry
    Social Class
    Spirit Of Life
    Spiritual Growth
    Stewardship
    Sunday
    Technology
    Theme-based Ministry
    Transient And Permanent
    War
    Western Unitarian Conference
    Widening The Circle
    Widening The Pathway
    William F. Schulz
    Working Class
    World Parliament Of Religions
    Worship

    RSS Feed


Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture

         revshariw (at) gmail (dot) com   |    531-600-8313

Picture
NO A.I. Training
details here
  • Home
  • About
    • Journey
    • Theology
    • Vocation
    • Honors
  • Ministry
    • Worship
    • Religious Education
    • Pastoral Care
    • Rites & RItuals
    • Creative Arts
  • Leadership
    • Social Action
    • Administration
    • Service
    • Personality
    • Beyond UU
  • Personal
    • Family
    • Interests
    • Gratitude
  • BLOGS
    • Savvy Seeker
    • Roots & Wings